In Baldur's Gate 3, one of the most pivotal choices arises near the game's conclusion: freeing the imprisoned Githyanki Prince Orpheus or allowing the Emperor to handle the situation. This decision, made after acquiring the Orphic Hammer, significantly impacts the party's fate.

Updated February 29, 2024, by Nahda Nabiilah: Before deciding Orpheus' fate, players must defeat Ketheric Throm, Lord Enver Gortash, and Orin—a task requiring thorough exploration of Baldur's Gate's upper and lower districts. This decision carries considerable weight; companions might sacrifice themselves, necessitating careful preparation and high rolls (potentially 30) to maintain their loyalty.

Spoiler Warning: The following discusses the game's ending.

To Free Orpheus or Not?

The choice hinges on player preferences. The Emperor warns that Orpheus' imprisonment prevents party members from becoming Illithids. Freeing him risks transforming one or more party members into Mind Flayers. After the Netherbrain battle (in the Astral Prism), the choice is presented: free Orpheus or let the Emperor absorb his power.

Siding with the Emperor: This leads to Orpheus' demise as the Emperor absorbs his knowledge. Lae'zel and Karlach may disapprove, impacting their personal quests. While this ensures victory against the Netherbrain, it might alienate fans of these characters.

Freeing Orpheus: This causes the Emperor to ally with the Netherbrain. A party member might still become a Mind Flayer. However, Orpheus joins the fight alongside the Githyanki, and will even sacrifice himself to prevent others from becoming Mind Flayers if asked.

In short: choose the Emperor to avoid becoming a Mind Flayer; choose Orpheus if you accept that risk for your companions. The Emperor's choice might cause Lae'zel's betrayal and force Karlach's return to Avernus.

The Moral Dilemma:

The "good" choice depends on your perspective, but ultimately revolves around loyalty. Orpheus, a rightful Githyanki ruler, opposes Vlaakith's tyranny. A Githyanki player might naturally side with him. However, following Voss and Lae'zel's demands might seem overly forceful to others. The Gith prioritize self-preservation, even if impacting the wider world.

The Emperor, conversely, is generally benevolent, aiming to defeat the Netherbrain and aid the party. He acknowledges the necessity of sacrifice. Choosing him might lead to becoming a Mind Flayer, but a morally upright one. Remember, BG3 offers multiple endings, allowing for outcomes that benefit everyone.